结核病与肺部健康杂志 ›› 2015, Vol. 4 ›› Issue (1): 23-27.doi: 10.3969/j.issn.2095-3755.2015.01.005

• 论著 • 上一篇    下一篇

直接数字化X线摄影在结核病暴发密切接触者筛查中的限度

王雪梅,李达,宋小意,路希维   

  1. 116033 大连市结核病医院
  • 收稿日期:2014-12-19 出版日期:2015-03-14 发布日期:2015-03-14
  • 通信作者: 路希维,Email:yiluxiwei@126.com

The value of DR in close contacts investigation in outbreak of tuberculosis

WANG Xue-mei, LI Da, SONG Xiao-yi, LU Xi-wei   

  1. Dalian Tuberculosis Hospital, Dalian 116033, China
  • Received:2014-12-19 Online:2015-03-14 Published:2015-03-14
  • Contact: LU Xi-wei,Email: yiluxiwei@126.com

摘要: 目的 评价直接数字化X线摄影(DR)在结核病暴发密切接触者筛查中的应用价值。方法 在2014年5月的一起结核病暴发事件中,对35例密切接触者同时进行DR和CT检查,通过DR与CT的对照研究,用卡方检验和ROC曲线下面积评价和计算DR对于肺隐蔽部位及不同性质病变的漏检情况。结果 DR和CT在本组密切接触者群体的异常阴影检出率分别为22.9%(8/35)和40.0%(14/35),两者检出率比较差异有统计学意义(χ2=16.154,P<0.01)。在DR漏检的6例微小病变中,因DR对肺解剖学隐匿部位识别不足漏诊3例,其中受肺门重叠遮挡1例,奇静脉食管隐窝微小病变1例,受下肺浓密肺纹理遮挡1例;因对6例中非解剖隐匿部位病变识别不足导致漏诊3例,早期树芽征是主要漏诊征象。经ROC曲线分析得出:早期树芽征长轴<22 mm时,DR检查容易导致漏诊。ROC曲线下面积(AUC)0.925。敏感度为90.0%,特异度为83.3%。对密切接触者检出的12例肺内异常阴影进行CT影像分析:病变累及1个肺段至5个肺段以上分别达58.3%(7/12)、16.7%(2/12)、8.3%(1/12)、8.3%(1/12)和16.7%(2/12)。病变累及范围<1个亚段的占41.7%(5/12);按照部位累及频度统计:上叶累及占66.7%(8/12),中叶和舌叶累及占16.7%(2/12),下叶累及占50.0%(6/12),下叶的累及频度明显增多。首发患者的影像学表现类型为空洞播散性,以空洞和树芽征为主要的征象群。密切接触者发病以树芽征为主要影像表现,占91.7%(11/12)。4例结核性胸膜炎患者均在治疗3~4个月后出现胸膜下结核瘤。胸膜改变检出患者中也表现为影像同质性。6例漏诊微小病变采取抗结核实验性治疗,强化期末病变显著吸收者仅2例,疗程结束后病变均显著吸收。结论 相对DR而言,CT在结核病暴发密切接触者的筛查中有重要价值。

Abstract: Objective To evaluate the value of DR in close contacts investigation in outbreak of tuberculosis. Methods Both DR and CT were taken to screen close contacts(35 cases) from the event of tuberculosis outbreak in May,2014,the missed detection of different kinds of lesion and hidden parts were evaluated with Chi-square test and area under ROC curve. Results Abnormal shadow detection rate of CT was 40.0%(14/35), and it was significantly higher than 22.9%(8/35)of DR,χ2 value was 16.154, P<0.01. In missed 6 cases with DR,due to anatomic conceal site accounted for 3 cases,such as hilar(1 case),azygos vein esophagus crypt(1 case) and thickening of the blood vessels in the lower lobe(1 case). Other reasons accounted for 50.0%. Early tree-in-bud signs were the major signs in missed cases. ROC analysis showed that the lesions, which the length of the major axis(cut off value) was not more than 22 mm, were undetected easily. Area under curve(AUC) was 0.925. The sensitivity and specificity were 90.0% and 83.3%, respectively. In 12 cases with abnormal shadow were detected by CT, lesions involving in one lung segment to more than five lung segments were 7 cases (58.3%), 2 cases (16.7%), 1 case (8.3%), 1 case (8.3%), and 2 cases (16.7%),respectively. Percentage of cases that involved less than one sub-segment was 41.7%(5/12). Frequency of lesions involved in the upper lobe,the mid-lingual lobe, and the lower lobe were 66.7%(8/12),16.7% (2/12) and 50.0% (6/12),respectively. CT images showed cavity-air spread type in the index case,and mainly including cavity and tree-in-bud sign.Tree in bud signs, which accounted for 91.7% (11/12), were the main CT characteristics in active pulmonary tuberculosis(PTB) among close contacts. All 4 cases of pleurisy patients appeared pleural tuberculoma after 3-4 months chemotherapy, and showed the same image characteristics. Six cases with micro-lesions were taken by anti-TB experimental treatment, the lesions of 2 cases was significantly absorbed after 2 months, and all the 6 cases absorbed after 6 months. Conclusion CT is more valuable in the screen of TB outbreak in school compared with DR. Subclinical cases detected by CT is recommended to take a formal anti-TB treatment.